Think you've got tenancy deposit protection sorted? Think again. Every week, landlords across London and Kent discover they've been unknowingly breaking the rules – sometimes for years. The penalties can be brutal: up to three times the deposit amount in fines, plus the inability to evict problem tenants.
But here's the thing: these mistakes are entirely preventable. Most stem from simple oversights or outdated practices that seemed fine until they weren't. As property inventory specialists who've documented thousands of tenancies across the South East, we've seen these errors destroy otherwise solid landlord-tenant relationships.
Let's dive into the seven most common tenancy deposit protection mistakes – and more importantly, how to fix them before they cost you thousands.
Mistake #1: The 30-Day Deadline Disaster
The most expensive mistake in the book? Missing the 30-day protection deadline. You must protect your tenant's deposit in a government-approved scheme within 30 calendar days of receiving it. Not working days. Not "when you get around to it." Thirty calendar days, full stop.
Miss this deadline, and you're looking at penalties of up to three times the deposit amount. Worse still, you can't serve a valid Section 21 notice until you've sorted it out. That problem tenant you want gone? They're staying put until you fix this mess.
The Fix: If you've already missed the deadline, you have two options. First, return the deposit to the tenant immediately – this allows you to serve a Section 21 notice. Second, protect the deposit as soon as possible. While this doesn't prevent a compensation claim, it may help reduce the damage in court.
Going forward, set calendar reminders the moment you receive a deposit. Better yet, protect it within a week of receipt. There's absolutely no benefit to waiting, and the risks are enormous.
Mistake #2: The Prescribed Information Fumble
Even if you protect the deposit on time, you're not done. You must also serve your tenant with complete prescribed information within the same 30-day window. This isn't just a quick email – it's a comprehensive package including the scheme's prescribed information template, scheme rules documentation, and the deposit protection certificate.
Many landlords get this spectacularly wrong. They'll protect the deposit but forget to send the paperwork, or they'll send incomplete information weeks later. The courts don't care about your good intentions – only compliance.
The Fix: Create a standard process. The moment you protect a deposit, immediately compile and send the complete prescribed information package. Include everything: the template, the rules, the certificate, and a signed covering letter. Make this part of your standard procedure, not an afterthought.
If you've already missed this deadline, serve the complete prescribed information immediately. While you can't undo the breach, prompt action may allow you to rely on a Section 21 notice and potentially reduce any compensation claims.
Mistake #3: The Incomplete Documentation Trap
Here's where attention to detail separates professional landlords from amateurs. The prescribed information must be complete, signed, and properly formatted. You can't pick and choose which documents to include – it's all or nothing.
Common errors include unsigned covering letters, missing deposit leaflets, or referencing incorrect clauses. The courts take a pragmatic approach to minor errors, but only if you've clearly attempted to comply with the full requirements.
The Fix: Create a checklist. Every prescribed information package should include:
- The scheme's prescribed information template (completed and signed)
- The scheme rules documentation
- The deposit protection certificate
- The scheme's deposit protection leaflet
- A signed covering letter referencing the correct tenancy
Double-check every document before sending. A property inventory report professional approach – meticulous attention to detail – prevents these easily avoidable errors.
Mistake #4: The Change Management Oversight
Property circumstances change. You might sell to another landlord, switch deposit protection schemes, or adjust the deposit amount. Each change requires action – specifically, re-protecting the deposit and serving updated prescribed information within 30 days.
This catches many experienced landlords off-guard. They assume the original protection covers all eventualities, but it doesn't. Every significant change resets the clock.
The Fix: Treat any change in deposit circumstances as a fresh deposit protection requirement. Whether you're transferring ownership, changing schemes, or adjusting amounts, immediately re-protect and serve new prescribed information.
Document these changes meticulously. Just as a professional property inventory report tracks every detail during tenancy transitions, your deposit protection records should capture every modification and compliance action.
Mistake #5: The Deposit Cap Catastrophe
Since June 2019, deposits in England are capped at five weeks' rent for properties under £50,000 annual rent, or six weeks' rent for higher-value properties. Yet many landlords still charge old-style deposits without realising they're breaking the law.
The Fix: Calculate your deposit cap immediately. For existing pre-2019 tenancies with excessive deposits, you're not required to refund the excess – but you can't increase it if the tenancy changes or renews.
For new tenancies, stick strictly to the caps. There's no legal workaround, and the penalties aren't worth the extra security you think you're getting.
Mistake #6: The Return Process Problems
After check-out, you should return any undisputed deposit amount promptly – ideally within 10 days. This requires comparing the property's condition against your check-in documentation. Without a proper property inventory report, you're flying blind.
Many landlords delay returns unnecessarily, creating tension and potential disputes. Others make arbitrary deductions without proper documentation to support their claims.
The Fix: Establish a systematic check-out process. Compare the property's condition against your detailed check-in inventory, document any changes with photographs and descriptions, and clearly communicate any proposed deductions to the tenant.
Return undisputed amounts quickly. If you're proposing deductions, explain them clearly with supporting evidence. Professional landlord inventory services ensure you have the documentation needed to support legitimate claims while avoiding frivolous disputes.
Mistake #7: The Compliance Complacency Error
Perhaps the most dangerous mistake is assuming you can fix deposit protection errors after the fact without consequences. Courts prioritise landlords' culpability over their subsequent attempts to comply. Ignorance isn't a defence, and neither is delayed compliance.
The Fix: Get it right from the start. Familiarise yourself with all deposit protection requirements before taking any deposit. Only accept deposits when you can comply with all statutory requirements immediately.
If you discover existing errors, address them immediately to mitigate potential damages. However, don't assume this prevents compensation claims – it simply demonstrates your commitment to compliance.
The Professional Advantage
These mistakes share a common thread: they're all preventable with proper systems and attention to detail. Professional property management isn't about complicated procedures – it's about consistent, meticulous compliance with straightforward requirements.
That's where the value of professional support becomes clear. Whether it's comprehensive property inventory reports that document tenancy conditions precisely, or systematic approaches to deposit protection compliance, professional standards prevent costly amateur errors.
At Evestaff, we've spent over a decade perfecting these processes across London and Kent. Our meticulous approach to documentation ensures landlords have the evidence they need to protect deposits legitimately while avoiding compliance pitfalls that catch others off-guard.
The three government-approved schemes – MyDeposits, Tenancy Deposit Scheme, and Deposit Protection Service – all work effectively when used correctly. The key is choosing one and following their procedures precisely, every time.
Remember: tenancy deposit protection isn't optional, and the penalties for getting it wrong are severe. But with proper systems and professional attention to detail, compliance becomes routine rather than risky.
For landlords serious about professional property management, combining proper deposit protection procedures with comprehensive inventory documentation creates the foundation for successful, legally compliant tenancies. It's not about perfection – it's about consistent professional standards that protect both landlords and tenants.
Your deposits, your tenancies, and your rental business deserve nothing less than complete compliance. The costs of getting it wrong are simply too high to risk.
Join The Discussion